Friday, July 12, 2013

Okada Riders Vs Edo Government. Judge to give verdict on October 4th 2013.

On the challenge on the ban on Okada in Edo State, we were @ the Federal High Court on Monday July 8th, 2013. The State Counsel representing the governor wanted to employ delay tactic by asking for a long adjournment but was stopped by the Judge who ordered that we come back on Wednesday the 10th to address the court. We went back and both our lawyer and the government lawyers presented their case. Finally the Judge said he will give Judgement on the 4th of October 2013. He said the delay in giving judgement was due to the fact that the court was going on recess as from the 15th of July 2013.

Friday, July 5, 2013

Thanks Ralph Odua for your support.

 I want to use this opportunity to thank Ralph Odua for placing financial resources at our disposal to pursue this case and mobilize the electorate. Ralph Odua we are proud of you. When we harness our various talents, we will together move mountains.

Thursday, July 4, 2013

My response to a post on my Facebook wall.

My response to Philo Asimu on my Facebook wall @ Philo Asimu the rights you are enjoying today in London were fought and won by people like me. I want my people to also the benefit from fundamental Human rights too. I am fighting for my people and the future generations, so that they do not have to go to other climes to enjoy these rights. In the future it will be said that when one Governor of Edo State VERBALLY ban Okada from our streets, that one Osbert Agho stood on the side of the people.That he went to the federal High Court in Benin to unshackle his people from poverty. That because he stood for the people the VERBAL decision of the governor was revised, that today people can ride Okada on the streets of Benin because that lover of Human rights fought on the side of the poor.

Be at the federal High Court on Monday 8th July. 2013

 @ All my joy will not know bonds if you all translate your support into making your presence at the Federal High court, Auchi Road behind INEC office @ Ikpoba Hill on Monday 8th July, 2013. According to one advert, it says you will NEVER walk alone. Please do not let me walk alone on this issue. Please come out enmass on Monday.

The challenge to the Ban on Okada and

 Here is a post by Emmanuel Ebesunun in the Edo Political Parliament when Frank Obaresan Okuokoni ask a lawyer to give an insight...... Emmanuel Ebesunun wrote... Very thorny question Frank Obaresan-Okoukoni especially as our courts have a habit of delivering very strange decisions when politics and politicians are involved. Anyway let me give it a try :

As a general rule govt has no power to deprive ANYONE of the use of his property, okada is property, and the right to the use of one's property is one of our God given rights [they are not constitutional rights as most people mistaken label them, the const ONLY protects our rights, it does not give them to us]. Now let us apply this general rule and the exceptions that follow it in the two available situations :

1. For private use; govt cannot prevent anyone from using his okada to move freely about his lawful business, to do so will be impeding the person's freedom of movement and depriving him of the right to the lawful use of his property. The only thing govt has power to do is make regulations as to how the okada can be used in the interest of the health and safety of the general public, e.g., require that the owner license it, require that anyone riding it have a valid license to so do, require that anyone riding it and/or being conveyed on it put on a crash helmet, etc.

2. The issue becomes more complicated when the okada is for commercial purposes, as I recall we have a hackney carriage law that deals with categories of vehicles that can be used for the commercial conveying of human beings, and okada is not listed, in fact okada for commercial use was not in practice as at the time the law was enacted. Does that mean that okada cant be used for commercial purposes?. There are two schools of thought on such an issue, the first is of the view that govt's regulatory power [in the interest of the health and welfare of the general society] can be used to decide what classes of vehicles are fit for commercial purposes, if the view of this first school of thougt is applied, govt has power to ban okada. The contrary school of thought is that govt CAN ONLY regulate to the extent of requiring licensing; equipment; and safe practices in the interest of the health and welfare of the general public. World wide, when it comes to commercial use, govt has always won the argument with the first school of thought except when there is some discriminatory intent and/or outcome and/or some other egregious circumstance implicated in the determination of whether a particular class of vehicle be used or not. Banning okada use in only 3 LGA has a clearly discriminatory impact/intent.

Bottom line?, it depends on the how the court is suaded one way or the other, so the okada riders better get the best available, and although now mute, avoid state courts while pursuing their remedies.

The above is a generalized overview, but let's look at the specifics from the post, did the governor verbally ban okadas?, he has no power to do so, that will amount to legislating/making laws, and only the House of Assembly has the power to pass laws subject to the govs accent in some cases. Even if there is an existing law banning okada, did he comply with the provisions pf that law when he announced the ban verbally?, if he did not comply with the provisions of the law then the ban in invalid!. Did the governor threaten to confiscate and burn okadas?, if he did then he has exceeded his powers, ONLY the courts have the power to pronounce a person guilty of a violation of laws/regulations, and only a court can impose punishment, confiscating and burning okada for the violation of any law banning their use is punishment fit only for imposition by the courts and not the governor. 

On Amechi's, the Rvivers State Governor car accident.

When you drive recklessly on the roads the end will always be accident. When your security drives with their heads our of the drivers window you will always be involved in an accident. When you drive in a convoy of 40 cars and using up 2000 litres of petrol just to go from point A to B a distance 8 kilometres you will always be in an accident. Rotimi Amaechi was in a self inflicted accident. He should stop heating up the polity.

Wednesday, July 3, 2013

The challenge to the Ban on Okada in the Federal High Court.

 Here is a post by Emmanuel Ebesunun in the Edo Political Parliament when Frank Obaresan Okuokoni ask a lawyer to give an insight...... Emmanuel Ebesunun wrote... Very thorny question Frank Obaresan-Okoukoni especially as our courts have a habit of delivering very strange decisions when politics and politicians are involved. Anyway let me give it a try :

As a general rule govt has no power to deprive ANYONE of the use of his property, okada is property, and the right to the use of one's property is one of our God given rights [they are not constitutional rights as most people mistaken label them, the const ONLY protects our rights, it does not give them to us]. Now let us apply this general rule and the exceptions that follow it in the two available situations :

1. For private use; govt cannot prevent anyone from using his okada to move freely about his lawful business, to do so will be impeding the person's freedom of movement and depriving him of the right to the lawful use of his property. The only thing govt has power to do is make regulations as to how the okada can be used in the interest of the health and safety of the general public, e.g., require that the owner license it, require that anyone riding it have a valid license to so do, require that anyone riding it and/or being conveyed on it put on a crash helmet, etc.

2. The issue becomes more complicated when the okada is for commercial purposes, as I recall we have a hackney carriage law that deals with categories of vehicles that can be used for the commercial conveying of human beings, and okada is not listed, in fact okada for commercial use was not in practice as at the time the law was enacted. Does that mean that okada cant be used for commercial purposes?. There are two schools of thought on such an issue, the first is of the view that govt's regulatory power [in the interest of the health and welfare of the general society] can be used to decide what classes of vehicles are fit for commercial purposes, if the view of this first school of thougt is applied, govt has power to ban okada. The contrary school of thought is that govt CAN ONLY regulate to the extent of requiring licensing; equipment; and safe practices in the interest of the health and welfare of the general public. World wide, when it comes to commercial use, govt has always won the argument with the first school of thought except when there is some discriminatory intent and/or outcome and/or some other egregious circumstance implicated in the determination of whether a particular class of vehicle be used or not. Banning okada use in only 3 LGA has a clearly discriminatory impact/intent.

Bottom line?, it depends on the how the court is suaded one way or the other, so the okada riders better get the best available, and although now mute, avoid state courts while pursuing their remedies.

The above is a generalized overview, but let's look at the specifics from the post, did the governor verbally ban okadas?, he has no power to do so, that will amount to legislating/making laws, and only the House of Assembly has the power to pass laws subject to the govs accent in some cases. Even if there is an existing law banning okada, did he comply with the provisions pf that law when he announced the ban verbally?, if he did not comply with the provisions of the law then the ban in invalid!. Did the governor threaten to confiscate and burn okadas?, if he did then he has exceeded his powers, ONLY the courts have the power to pronounce a person guilty of a violation of laws/regulations, and only a court can impose punishment, confiscating and burning okada for the violation of any law banning their use is punishment fit only for imposition by the courts and not the governor. 

The Ban on Okada and

 Here is a post by Emmanuel Ebesunun in the Edo Political Parliament when Frank Obaresan Okuokoni ask a lawyer to give an insight...... Emmanuel Ebesunun wrote... Very thorny question Frank Obaresan-Okoukoni especially as our courts have a habit of delivering very strange decisions when politics and politicians are involved. Anyway let me give it a try :

As a general rule govt has no power to deprive ANYONE of the use of his property, okada is property, and the right to the use of one's property is one of our God given rights [they are not constitutional rights as most people mistaken label them, the const ONLY protects our rights, it does not give them to us]. Now let us apply this general rule and the exceptions that follow it in the two available situations :

1. For private use; govt cannot prevent anyone from using his okada to move freely about his lawful business, to do so will be impeding the person's freedom of movement and depriving him of the right to the lawful use of his property. The only thing govt has power to do is make regulations as to how the okada can be used in the interest of the health and safety of the general public, e.g., require that the owner license it, require that anyone riding it have a valid license to so do, require that anyone riding it and/or being conveyed on it put on a crash helmet, etc.

2. The issue becomes more complicated when the okada is for commercial purposes, as I recall we have a hackney carriage law that deals with categories of vehicles that can be used for the commercial conveying of human beings, and okada is not listed, in fact okada for commercial use was not in practice as at the time the law was enacted. Does that mean that okada cant be used for commercial purposes?. There are two schools of thought on such an issue, the first is of the view that govt's regulatory power [in the interest of the health and welfare of the general society] can be used to decide what classes of vehicles are fit for commercial purposes, if the view of this first school of thougt is applied, govt has power to ban okada. The contrary school of thought is that govt CAN ONLY regulate to the extent of requiring licensing; equipment; and safe practices in the interest of the health and welfare of the general public. World wide, when it comes to commercial use, govt has always won the argument with the first school of thought except when there is some discriminatory intent and/or outcome and/or some other egregious circumstance implicated in the determination of whether a particular class of vehicle be used or not. Banning okada use in only 3 LGA has a clearly discriminatory impact/intent.

Bottom line?, it depends on the how the court is suaded one way or the other, so the okada riders better get the best available, and although now mute, avoid state courts while pursuing their remedies.

The above is a generalized overview, but let's look at the specifics from the post, did the governor verbally ban okadas?, he has no power to do so, that will amount to legislating/making laws, and only the House of Assembly has the power to pass laws subject to the govs accent in some cases. Even if there is an existing law banning okada, did he comply with the provisions pf that law when he announced the ban verbally?, if he did not comply with the provisions of the law then the ban in invalid!. Did the governor threaten to confiscate and burn okadas?, if he did then he has exceeded his powers, ONLY the courts have the power to pronounce a person guilty of a violation of laws/regulations, and only a court can impose punishment, confiscating and burning okada for the violation of any law banning their use is punishment fit only for imposition by the courts and not the governor. 

Tuesday, July 2, 2013

Obama refusal to visit Nigeria.

On Obama refusal to visit Nigeria....  Down the road President Obama is going to want to visit Nigeria, probably nearing the end of his tenure. My advice to GEJ is that he should not to accept that visit. It will be a disgrace to Nigeria and the African/Black people if he accept. Then it will be on record that the first Black President of the USA did not visit the most populous country in the African continent.